NuVet Supplement=Same Old Snake Oil

A client recently asked me about a product, NuVet supplement, which after a little investigation seems to be the yet another fine example of snake oil marketing. It is quite similar to a product I reviewed not that long ago, Protandim, though all quack remedies share a lot of characteristics (as my reviews of DogtorRx, Supraglan, and others illustrate). Many of these characteristics are classic warning signs of snake oil, and in the case of NuVet, these include:

A “kitchen-sink” mixture of vitamins, minerals, herbs, and other ingredients, some of which are essential nutrients or have individually shown some interesting properties in test tubes and mice, but none of which shown to be safe and effective in treating or preventing any disease in dogs or cats.

This hodgepodge is advertised as treating many unrelated diseases (cataracts, Cushing’s diseases, diabetes, allergies, etc) with good results and no risks. These include:

Vague claims are made about treating “oxidative stress” and “inflammation”, with the implication that “anti-oxidant” and “anti-inflammatory” agents must automatically be safe and beneficial.

Glowing testimonials are offered to support the wild claims made, but not a single clinical study has been done to demonstrate the truth of any of them.

A money-back guarantee is offered, though how this compensates for the suffering or even death of your pet caused by relying on an untested and probably useless remedy isn’t really clear.

Too good to be true? You bet!

What Is It?
The two products NuVet promotes are NuVet Plus and the NuJoint Plus. The joint supplement contains glucosamine, chondroitin, and MSM. I have written about these ingredients before (1, 2) and the bottom line is that human and animal research evidence strongly suggests there is no benefit to taking these products for people or animals with arthritis. Barring contamination with something toxic, which happens surprisingly often due to the lack of effective regulation of supplements, NuJoint is probably harmless and useless.

The ingredient list for NuVet is much longer:

Alfalfa (Canine formula only) Alpha Amylase Amino Acids Beta Carotene Blue Green Algae Brewer’s Yeast Cat’s Claw Chicken Liver Copper Evening Primrose Oil Iron L Methionine Magnesium Manganese Oyster Shell Papain Phosphorus Pine Bark Potassium Selenium (Yeast) Shark Cartilage Taurine (Feline formula only) Vitamin A Vitamin B Complex Vitamin B1 (Thiamine) Vitamin B2 (Riboflavin) Vitamin B3 (Niacin) Vitamin B5 (Pantothenic Acid) Vitamin B6 (Pyridoxine) Vitamin B12 Vitamin C (Ester C™) Vitamin E Whey Protein (Feline formula only) Zinc

Talk about everything but the kitchen sink! The rationales given for the inclusion of each range from vague descriptions of what the normal role of some of the nutrients is in the body to totally unsupported assertions about supposed magical clinical benefits. I will address these claims in a moment.

The story behind the “discovery” of this elixir is either a perfect example of the naïve and unscientific thinking that should warn consumers they are being offered snake oil, or it is a carefully crafted marketing gimmick.

It all began years ago when I was noticing certain changes in my beloved furry companion, Elvis…Even though I had always cared for him and tried to give him the best food available, it became apparent that Elvis needed something more. After several trips to our veterinarian and at a cost that I don’t even want to think about, I was left to try and find a solution on my own. All the medications and changes to his diet wasn’t making any kind of significant difference and I feared my best buddy was quickly slipping away from me. I tried all kinds of vitamin and herbal supplements because I knew there was something his body needed that he wasn’t getting but I just couldn’t find the right stuff.

It occurred to me that, like my Elvis, many other dogs and cats were not taking a sufficient regimen of vitamins, minerals and antioxidants equivalent to advanced human supplements used to fight against the damaging effects of free radicals, which are a major cause of disease. I thought that the right combination, in the exact formulation, using only the highest quality of ingredients, would be required to rid pets of these damaging elements and would create a scenario for greater health and a much longer life span.

Blake G. Kirschbaum President

Mr. Kirschbaum goes on to claim his product is needed because of “obvious” deficiencies in conventional pet diets.

Because most pets lack proper nutrients such as vitamins, minerals, and antioxidants in their diet, even when they are getting the top of the line food, NuVet® scientists understood the necessity of filling this dangerous gap. Commercial pet foods can contain harmful “by-products” and useless fillers that can be toxic to pets, causing allergies and serious diseases. This kind of atypical diet creates a scenario whereby their food may actually be creating unstable oxygen molecules known as Free Radicals.

The next step after this brilliant insight was to set up a crack team to develop and promote the magic supplement all dogs and cats apparently need.

I decided to take matters into my own hands and established NuVet Labs®. I put together a team of highly respected scientific, medical and pet industry professionals that had the same goal as I did; to create a nutritional product that would go beyond current supplements that only gave symptomatic relief. Our objective was to make a truly effective nutritional supplement that would attack the root cause of sickness and disease, eliminating the free radicals and other sources of the problem, once and for all. This became my mission and although it took our team 8 years to perfect the formula, we finally got it right. An independent laboratory tested several dogs and cats, varying in age, size, and health conditions, under the direct supervision of a team of veterinarians. 

Our Advisory Team is composed of a veterinarian, a doctor of pharmacy, a pet supplement and pet food formulator, a doctor of optometry, a licensed financial advisor, a litigation insurance administrator and a senior hospital purchasing manager.

Eight years of effort dedicated to solving the root causes of all disease finally vindicated by an unpublished test in “several dogs and cats.” Wow!

I have added the emphasis above to highlight the pre-existing faith Mr. Kirshbaum evinces in the nature of his dog’s health problems (nutrient deficiency and free radical damage) and the solution (the “right” supplement), as well as the astounding arrogance and naïveté  this narrative demonstrates. The very foundational principles behind this product are unproven and scientifically empty beliefs, not well-established principles of health and disease. And the claim being made is that the One True Cause of disease, and its solution, which has eluded all scientists everywhere in the world has now been cooked up by one visionary and his small team of mavericks Not a good start.

Does It Work?
The underlying theory that all these disparate chronic diseases for which scientific medicine does not have a definitive cause or cure are caused by oxidative damage due to poor diets is nonsense. While free radicals exist and do cause cellular damage and even disease, this little core of real science has been rebuilt into a bogeyman that bears no resemblance to the truth. Like all overly broad and simplistic ideas, the oxidative damage hypothesis has proven far less robust than initial enthusiasm for it would have suggested, and many purported anti-oxidants have turned out to provide little benefit in preventing or treating disease, and even in some cases have been shown to be actively harmful (e.g. 3, 4, 5).

While many of the individual ingredients in the product are essential nutrients, there is absolutely no reason to believe that they provide any health benefits except in cases in which a pet is deficient in a specific nutrient. Providing excessive vitamins and minerals to prevent or treat diseases is seldom beneficial and, again, sometimes actively harmful (e.g. 6, 7, 8).  And there is extensive evidence to show that while commercial diets are by no means perfect, they are not the deleterious pile of toxins and garbage described by those who are trying to sell supplements (e.g. 9, 10).

As for the other ingredients:

Alpha Amylase: There is no truth to the claim that digestive enzymes are beneficial for normal animals (11)

Bluegreen Algae- There is no reliable evidence to support the health claims NuVet makes for this ingredient (12). And some species of bluegreen can be highly toxic, especially to dogs (13).

Brewer’sYeatst- A source of B vitamins, but not an effective flea control product (14).

Cat’s Claw- There is weak clinical evidence in humans of anti-inflammatory properties to some of the chemicals in this herb, and there are also reports of serious side-effects (15). There is no controlled research evidence to show safety or any benefits in dogs and cats.

Evening Primrose Oil- There is limited evidence for benefits treating eczema in humans, and otherwise no solid evidence of benefit for any other disease (16). It may be a good source of essential fatty acids, which could theoretically have some benefits for allergic skin disease or arthritis. Obviously, the claims concerning cholesterol and atherosclerosis are irrelevant since dogs and cats do not suffer from this disease.

Papain- There is limited evidence for benefits of papain in humans for shingles and sore throat, and no reliable evidence for any other benefits (17). There is no reason to believe it has value as a “digestive enzyme,” and the limited research on it as a hairball remedy in cats and rabbits has not shown any real benefit.

Pine Bark Extract- There is some laboratory and animal model evidence that chemicals in this extract have anti-inflammatory and anti-oxidant activity, but actual clinical benefits have not been demonstrated in human or animal clinical trials (18). As always for any chemical with real physiologic activities, there is the potential for side-effects (19). I am not aware of any clinical trials investigating the use of this ingredient in dogs or cats.

Shark Cartilage- Shark cartilage has been proven ineffective for advanced cancers of various kinds, and there is inadequate evidence to show benefit for any other condition (20, 21). The harvesting of sharks for this supplement as well as for food contributes to the decline of threatened and endangered shark species (22).

And finally, as well as most important, there appears to be  absolutely no published research evidence of any kind evaluating the safety or purported benefits of this product. That is not a good sign.

Is It Safe?
As indicated for the specific ingredients above, harm can result from indiscriminate use of even essential nutrients. The amounts of each ingredient in the final product are not made available to the public, so it is impossible to evaluate the safety of the doses even for those ingredients for which safe and unsafe levels have been established.

Due to the inadequate regulation of dietary supplements and herbal products, it is impossible to ensure the accuracy of ingredient lists or the absence of dangerous contaminants, both of which have been real problems for such products (23, 24). There is also no formal system for collecting and evaluating reports of harm from such products, so the only assurance of the safety of the product is the word of the manufacturer.

Bottom Line
This product is a hodgepodge of nutrients, herbal ingredients, and nutraceuticals thrown together with no clear logic or rationale. The claims that many pet diseases are due to toxins or other deficiencies in commercial diets and to oxidative damage are unsupported by any real evidence. Only a few of the specific claims for the ingredients in the mixture are backed by research evidence, and the quality of this is generally poor and only available for humans. The advertising of the product contains many of the hallmarks of snake oil marketing, but it does not contain any research evidence at all concerning the safety or effectiveness of the product, because none appears to exist.

While I have no reason to doubt the sincerity of the manufacturer of this product, I believe it is unethical to sell a product with no research establishing the safety or efficacy of the product for any disease and with little to no research even into the safety and efficacy of its constituents. Promoting the product with unproven or outright false claims about pet nutrition and disease designed to instill fear in pet owners and with wild and ridiculous claims about the effectiveness of the product for numerous unrelated diseases is wrong regardless of how sincerely the manufacturer believes in their own pseudoscientific theories. Any responsible manufacturer of a medical therapy should be expected to demonstrate their claims through rigorous science before profiting from the desperate need of people with sick pets.









This entry was posted in Herbs and Supplements. Bookmark the permalink.

113 Responses to NuVet Supplement=Same Old Snake Oil

  1. YinMei Quan says:

    JohnBoz: Thank you for those comforting words, I miss her so much more than I thought I would. A very trusted friend gave me the same advice, to love another dog, and I have thought about saving one from a shelter. Blessings.

  2. YinMei Quan says:

    Kristin: SkeptVet is correct to say there is no evidence a simple supplement would be the answer to shrink tumours, but absent any other treatment, there is no reason not to try. I have noticed all the anecdotal stories are about external tumours – not on the tongue though. In my situation, my dog began falling down when taken for a walk – this was the beginning of the end. I stopped walking her on concrete and stuck to grassy areas, fearing a face plant from her front legs giving out. It happened twice. About two weeks later she could not walk at all, I had to carry her outside to do her business and thats when I made the call. Even at this stage, she was still wagging her tail whenever we made eye contact. She was such a good girl. There was not a dry eye in the house the day … anyway, don’t wait. Days matter. Eventually, oblivion calls for all living things. I wish you and your pup all the strength you need at this time.

  3. Serena says:

    I have 2 of my dogs on nu vet plus due to skin issues. They both had terrible red patches that they would scratch until raw. We were at the vet several times, always steroids, it was a temporary fix. I tried nu vet just to see, on one dog first, after the initial 30 days, it was a miracle, in the 4 years they have been taking it they haven’t had any problems at all. I don’t need research and tests to know it helped both of my dogs. They are 14 and 16 and doing well, the 14 year old is just starting to get arthritis I’m staying him on nu joint immediately. I know you’re at vet but you need to talk to the people who are giving this to their pets, I realize not everything works on everyone’s pet. It’s worth a try, I wouldn’t believe claims of curing cancer from any product, as no one should,, unfortunately there are no miracle cures for cancer in humans or pets and no product should say it, I do believe in vitamins and minerals for me and my dogs and I believe it has made them healthier and more comfortable. All my dogs are over 14.

  4. Janet says:

    I am so happy I stumbled across your blogs while I was on hold with NuVet to reorder the NuVet Plus and the NuJoint for my 10 yr old Golden. Needless to say I hung up before I was connected to anyone. They initially sold me two bottles of NuVet to reduce all the fatty tumors my girl has developed. When I told them after almost 2 months of giving the max dose of 4 wafers a day there was no difference so I was checking to see how to get my refund? Instead I got suckered into purchasing another 2-month supply and I was going to try the NuJoint to as she’s becoming lame lately due to age. Right now I’m feeding her Wellness Simple dry/moist for dinner mixing in Missing Link Plus & salmon oil. I was curious about your thoughts on Missing Link, do you feel this is a good supplement? Thank you so much for making so many of aware what a scam NuVet is. Sure wish you were my vet, so wise & knowledgeable! ????

  5. skeptvet says:

    Thanks, Janet, for the comment. I am glad this article was useful for you.

    In general, vitamin and mineral supplements haven’t been shown to be necessary or beneficial in dogs eating a balanced commercial diet. And recent studies in humans suggest some risks associated with excessive vitamin supplementation. So the best I can say about any of these products, including missing link, is that nobody really knows if they will help, hurt, or do nothing at all for your dog since no research has been done on the question. Of course, there are lots of anecdotes and testimonials, but as I try to point out here, these aren’t reliable indicators of what is true.

    Salmon oil is a good source of certain fatty acids which may be helpful for dogs with allergic skin disease or arthritis, but again there is no reason for most dogs to be on them.

    Good luck, and thanks again.

  6. S Heffner says:

    I should have done more research on this product before spending over a hundred dollars on it. I noticed after a week of giving what was suggested to me via phone conversation with them,my dog would have times of peeing in the house. This was normal for him and after research I discovered others having the same problem. I have no idea why it was happening but I stopped them and no problem since.

  7. sobiewan says:

    I ordered NuVet for my dogs because sadly, one of my precious Shih Tzus was diagnosed with lung and esophageal cancer. It was too late for her but we thought that at least we could do everything we could to try and protect our other dogs from certain health risk. We did not think of NuVet as a miracle, just a possible “help” or a measure of “protection”
    Our other Shih Tzu after six days began showing an extreme allergic reaction to something. Terrible, uncontrolled itching, red raised welps all over his body and one large knot on his head. He was genuinely suffering. Since we live in an area very prone to fire ants, we were just sure that he must have been bitten by fire ants but,since he had only been on NuVet a short time we stopped the NuVet just in case. His treatment required heavy doses of Prednisone and Benedyl to bring the condition under control. We kept him off of NuVet for three weeks and then started him again. We gave him a half a tablet the first two days and then a whole tablet on the third day. But the fourth day the itching had started again. He also, developed what could only be described as a scary egglike knot on the back of his head! We immediately stopped the NuVet and started the Benadryl. It is our belief that his condition is a result of some sort of reaction to something in the NuVet. We have removed him from NuVet and he will not take it again. We do have a Schnauzer taking NuVet but now we are so nervous about what we have seen with our Shih Tzu that although the Schnauzer has shown no reaction to NuVet, we will not continue our use of this product. I cannot speak for whether this product is a good product for others, I can only tell you our experience. I hope this will help others to weigh out the advantages or disadvantages for their beloved pet.

  8. Mfernflower says:

    Another day, Another mix of the same herbs and vitamins that cant really be proven or disprove to do a darn thing. Normally I would just look over this with jaded eyes but this supplement had a little surprise in it, Shark! Not only are you wasting money on something that probably doesn’t do anything, your also buying something made via illegal animal harvesting! (On a unrelated note I personally found that two over the counter vitamins that ever did anything for me, riboflavin for headaches and methylcobalmin for joint pain – As always ask a doctor before doing this stuff!)

  9. Jo says:

    Reports of lead in brewers and nutritional yeast=is there any lead in NUVET brewers yeast?

  10. skeptvet says:

    As usual, the problem is that there is no way to know since there is no meaningful regulatory oversight for these products.

  11. Corey taylor says:

    I used to work for the nuvet company. Hundreds of these bottles went out everyday.
    The guy has made millions by now

  12. ebdebroughton says:

    We just purchased a German Shepherd from a breeder who is pushing this stuff, he said he wouldn’t breed a dog who wasn’t on it. What kind of kick back are these pushers getting? I felt like this was some pyramid scam, having to use the dedicated order code.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Spam Protection by WP-SpamFree