One of the most common questions regarding veterinary nutrition that I get from clients these days is about cats and grains. An argument often made about feline nutrition is that because they are obligate carnivores, cats are ill-equipped to eat carbohydrates and that since commercial diets often include grains and other carbohydrate sources, these must be nutritionally inappropriate for cats. This argument is especially tricky because it is partially correct and partially a fallacy. It is true that cats are obligate carnivores, and diets that exclude all animal products are nearly impossible to make so that they will meet cats’ nutritional needs. On the other hand, there is a significant difference between nutrients in a diet and the ingredients in the diet. Proteins and carbohydrates derived from plant sources can be just as digestible and nutritious for cats as those derived from animal sources. The devil is in the details, and it is usually unwise and inaccurate to make sweeping generalizations about pet nutrition.
A panel of nutrition and feline medicine experts from the American College of Veterinary Medicine (ACVIM) recently drafted a consensus statement on the role of dietary carbohydrates in feline obesity and diabetes which examines some of the evidence concerning dietary carbohydrates and cats. This statement clarifies some questions but also leaves room for debate because it is based not on pure theory and argument but on research evidence, and there are areas in which the research evidence is inconclusive. This sort of ambiguity can be quite frustrating, but it is better to acknowledge the limits of our understanding and work towards expanding them than to simply take the lack of definitive information as an excuse to accept and promote whatever theoretical argument most appeals to us.
The statement was presented at the recent ACVIM annual meeting in the form of a series of questions about dietary carbohydrates in feline diets with brief answers and then an assessment of the strength of the evidence supporting these answers. The statement itself should be published soon, and will doubtless instigate vigorous debate, as it should. I will post a link to the statement and updates as they become available. But for now, here is a summary of the statement as presented at the recent conference.
1. Are dietary carbohydrates an essential or required nutrient for cats?
Answer- No. Based on a good quality and quantity of evidence, most cats do not require dietary carbohydrates. There are some simple sugars in feline milk, so it is possible that nursing kittens may require these but no clear deficiency has been demonstrated.
2. Can cats effectively utilize dietary carbohydrates for energy and nutrition?
Answer- Yes. Based on a good quality and quantity of evidence, cats can effectively digest, absorb, and utilize dietary carbohydrates.
3. Do dietary carbohydrates in the diet cause obesity?
Answer- No. The cause of obesity in almost all cats is excessive calorie intake irrespective of whether the calories come from protein, fat, or carbohydrate. In fact, low carbohydrate foods may be more likely to lead to obesity if they are higher in fat than regular diets.
4. Do dietary carbohydrates contribute to the development of diabetes?
Answer- The consensus was that they do not, however the research evidence is very limited and not always consistent. The consensus was that even if carbohydrates do play a role as a risk factor for diabetes, this is dwarfed by the much more important factor of obesity.
5. Are low-carbohydrate diets useful in the management of feline diabetes?
Answer-Maybe. The evidence is limited and conflicting, and the committee did not achieve a consensus.
The lead presenter summarized the central finding of the panel with three words:
“It’s the calories, Stupid!”
What would the answer to number five be if the question was about humans not cats. Would you get a maybe answer also?
Art malernee dvm
Fla lic 1820
Your page is ranked low in WOT, and this comment appeared: “This site has been compromised and is being used for redirection to fake av scanners through BHSEO pages injected by the hackers.”
Can you please check out your pages integrity?
I recently received a message from my host that the problem had been identified and fixed. Apparently, the problem was with the main page in the domain, not the blog, and since I don’t update the mian page often I wasn’t aware of it.
Looks like it’s the calories stupid in human diabetes also.
Art mavlernee dvm
Fla lic 1820
Should a problem like feline obesity be looked at in isolation?
Can a high carbohydrate diet really provide optimum nutrition?
What about the evidence that cats are not designed to consume carbohydrates and water deficient diets can have such negative impacts on cats?
(See JAVMA article, “The carnivore connection to nutrition in cats”
by Debra L. Zoran, PhD (nutrition), Diplomate, MS, DVM, BS, Associate Professor, Department of Small Animal Clinical Sciences, College of Veterinary Medicine, Texas A&M University, article found on catinfo (dot) org.)
While cats can survive on a high carbohydrate, low-calorie diet, do they thrive on it?
With the high numbers of cats with urinary problems and the fact they have low thirst drives, should cats be eating kibble? A study demonstrated that even giving cats water fountains to drink from did not translate to an increase in water consumption in (See Water Fountains for Cats on
winnfelinehealth (dot) blogspot (dot) com)
I don’t think the question of what is an “optimal” diet for cats has been definitively answered. And given the inherent variation among individuals, there probably isn’t any general rule that can be universally applied. Obviously, calories and micronutrients in appropriate amounts are necessary, and certainly most commercial diets meet that criterion, whereas most homemade diets do not. And there is no question that the natural history of the cat has implications for what is an appropriate diet. But our extrapolations from “natural” to “optimal” often turn out to be wrong, so they cannot stand alone as guidelines for what we should feed. They need to be examined through comprehensive scientific testing. Most theoretical propositions for how to feed cats that are based on their carniovorous natural history haven’t been tested, and so while they are reasonable hypotheses, they are not yet rules we can insist be followed.
The point of this review of the evidence was simply that while it makes sense that the ratio of carbohydrates to fat and protein in the diet would play a role in the development of obesity and diabetes meelitus, the evidence clearly shows that blindly following the “low-carb” hypothesis leads to fat cats that are less healthy and more likely to be diabetic. This illustrates why even reasonable hypotheses need to be properly examined. Perhaps canned diets will turn out to be better in terms of urinary tract health and weight management for cats. I tend to believe they are and recommend them myself. But I also point out that definitive evidence to support this idea does not yet exist, so my recommendation is a best guess and provisional.
Pingback: Why Is My Sphynx Cat Always Hungry? The Sphynx’s High Metabolism Explained – Pet Vet Tips