Author Archives: skeptvet

Veterinary Quackery–Circa 1921

I recently ran across an edition of the Journal of the American Veterinary Medical Association from 1921 which contained a few tidbits that I found interesting concerning the distinction between scientifically trained veterinarians and their “empirical” competitors. Such documents are … Continue reading

Posted in General | 2 Comments

“Holistic Medicine”–It means whatever we say it means

The American Holistic Veterinary Medical Association (AHVMA) has a statement on their web site explaining what “holistic” medicine is. I was interested in this because it’s a slippery word, seemingly simple on the surface but hard to pin down. Superficially, … Continue reading

Posted in General | 13 Comments

Spinmaster Messonier at it again

I recently discussed, and corrected, some comments Dr. Shawn Messonier made on his blog concerning Alison Averis’ post here illustrating how personal experience can be unreliable in evaluating whether a medical treatment works or not. Dr. Messonier has responded to … Continue reading

Posted in General | 2 Comments

Give a Dog a Bone (Not!)–FDA warns of dangers of feeding bones to dogs

The Food and Drug Administration issue a warning about feeding bones to dogs recently. Just like feeding milk to cats (which also isn’t a very good idea), giving bones to dogs is a cultural cliché that we learn about as … Continue reading

Posted in Nutrition | 21 Comments

Does science affect people’s beliefs? For good or ill?

The fundamental belief underlying this blog is that the truth matters, and that science is the best hope we have of approaching a true understanding of health and disease. I make an effort to investigate and understand the scientific evidence … Continue reading

Posted in General | Leave a comment

Primal Defense-An example of why I am suspicious of probiotics.

For those who have read what I have previously written about probiotics, you’ll know that I am cautiously optimistic about their potential usefulness as a medical therapy, despite the tendency towards overstating the results of the limited clinical trials so … Continue reading

Posted in Herbs and Supplements | 94 Comments

Dr. Shawn on Alison Averis’ Essay Fooling Yourself

The tireless promoter of “natural” veterinary medicine (whatever that is) and himself, Dr. Shawn Messonier, has applied his characteristic fuzzy logic and love of strawmen and misleading hyperbole to a recent guest post by Alison Averis on Fooling yourself: An … Continue reading

Posted in General | 4 Comments

The Mysterious Vanishing Placebo Effect?

I have written about the placebo effect before, but a recent update to a Cochrane review entitled Placebo Interventions for All Conditions has prompted me to revisit the subject. It has been clear for some time that the so-called placebo … Continue reading

Posted in General | 2 Comments

What Scientists Say and What the Public Hears

There are many barriers to public understanding of science and scientific research, ranging from low levels of science literacy in the general population to frequently  poor communication skills among scientists. I recently ran across a pithy summary of some common … Continue reading

Posted in General | 10 Comments

The Dunning-Kruger Effect: Why incompetence is blind to itself.

“The trouble with the world is that the stupid are cocksure and the intelligent are full of doubt.” Bertrand Russell “Ignorance more frequently begets confidence than does knowledge.” Charles Darwin “It is one of the essential features of such incompetence … Continue reading

Posted in General | 8 Comments